Buy vs Rent Calculator
Enter the home, the mortgage and the rent you would pay instead. The calculator follows both paths from the same starting cash and shows which one leaves you with more, year by year. Nothing to sign up for.
Net worth if you buy, end of year 10
€161,589.26
Net worth if you rent, end of year 10
€155,767.39
Buying comes out ahead by
€5,821.87
Buying pulls ahead at the end of year 9.
Both paths start with €81,000.00. In the first month owning costs €1,327.71, of which €1,077.71 is the mortgage payment, and renting costs €1,100.00.
Year by year
Net worth on each path at the end of every year. For buying, it is what selling would leave after selling costs and repaying the loan, plus any investments.
| Year | Home value | Loan owed | Net worth buying | Net worth renting | Buying minus renting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase | €300,000.00 | €240,000.00 | €45,000.00 | €81,000.00 | -€36,000.00 |
| Year 1 | €306,000.00 | €235,394.06 | €55,305.94 | €87,844.60 | -€32,538.66 |
| Year 2 | €312,120.00 | €230,624.31 | €65,889.69 | €94,822.79 | -€28,933.10 |
| Year 3 | €318,362.40 | €225,684.90 | €76,759.38 | €101,937.07 | -€25,177.69 |
| Year 4 | €324,729.65 | €220,569.81 | €87,923.36 | €109,189.99 | -€21,266.63 |
| Year 5 | €331,224.24 | €215,272.80 | €99,390.23 | €116,584.11 | -€17,193.88 |
| Year 6 | €337,848.73 | €209,787.39 | €111,168.90 | €124,122.16 | -€12,953.26 |
| Year 7 | €344,605.70 | €204,106.88 | €123,268.53 | €131,806.76 | -€8,538.23 |
| Year 8 | €351,497.81 | €198,224.34 | €135,698.58 | €139,640.71 | -€3,942.13 |
| Year 9 | €358,527.77 | €192,132.58 | €148,468.80 | €147,626.59 | +€842.21 |
| Year 10 | €365,698.33 | €185,824.15 | €161,589.26 | €155,767.39 | +€5,821.87 |
What the comparison shows
Buying swaps rent for mortgage payments, but it also ties up cash in the down payment and purchase costs and adds the costs of owning. Renting leaves that cash free to invest. The calculator follows both paths from the same starting cash and compares what each one leaves you with.
- Net worth on each path: for buying, what selling the home would leave after selling costs and repaying the loan, plus anything invested; for renting, the investments.
- The difference: how far ahead one path is at the end of the period you chose.
- The break-even year: the first year that ends with buying ahead. Buying starts behind whenever there are purchase or selling costs: the purchase costs are spent on day one, and selling straight away would cost the selling costs on top. Buying can also pull ahead and fall behind again, for example when the home's value grows more slowly than the renter's investments.
- The chart and the table show both paths every year, so you can see whether the gap is closing or widening.
Worked example
A home costs €300,000. You put down €60,000 (20%) and borrow €240,000 at 3.5% over 30 years. Purchase costs of 7% add €21,000, so buying takes €81,000 of cash. The same home rents for €1,100 a month. The rest are the calculator's starting assumptions: rent up 2% a year, the home's value up 2% a year, ownership costs of 1% of the value a year, a 5% return on investments and 5% selling costs, over 10 years.
On day one the renter invests the €81,000. The owner's stake is the €60,000 down payment less €15,000 of selling costs, €45,000, so buying starts €36,000 behind.
In the first month owning costs €1,327.71: €1,077.71 of mortgage payment and €250.00 of ownership costs. The rent is €1,100.00, so the renter invests the €227.71 difference. In this example owning costs more than renting in every month of the 10 years, so the owner never has money left over to invest.
After 10 years the home is worth €365,698.33. Selling it costs €18,284.92 and repays the €185,824.15 still owed, which leaves the owner €161,589.26. The renter's investments have grown to €155,767.39, so buying ends €5,821.87 ahead.
€365,698.33 − €18,284.92 − €185,824.15 = €161,589.26
€161,589.26 − €155,767.39 = €5,821.87
Buying first pulls ahead at the end of year 9. The answer depends on the assumptions: at a rent of €1,000 a month instead, renting is still €10,946.68 ahead after 10 years.
How the comparison is calculated
The calculator works month by month, in cents, from the day of purchase.
- Both paths start with the same cash: the down payment plus the purchase costs. The owner spends it on the home; the renter invests all of it.
- The mortgage is the one the mortgage calculator works out: a fixed rate, with each month's payment set from the balance still owed. Payments stop once the loan is repaid.
- Each month the owner pays the mortgage and a twelfth of the year's ownership costs, and the renter pays the rent. Whichever path costs less that month invests the difference.
- The home's value changes once a year by the growth rate. Ownership costs are a percentage of the value at the start of each year, so they change with it. The rent rises once a year by the rent increase.
- Investments grow each month at the monthly rate that compounds to the annual return over a year.
- At the end of each year the owner's net worth is the home's value less selling costs and the loan still owed, plus their investments. The renter's is their investments. The break-even year is the first year that ends with the owner ahead.
Buying = home value − selling costs − loan owed + investments
Renting = investments
Monthly return = (1 + R)1/12 − 1
Here R is the annual investment return, so 5% a year gives about 0.407% a month.
What it leaves out
- Tax on investment gains or on the profit from selling the home.
- A rent deposit, and anything it could earn.
- Mortgage interest tax relief and other tax breaks for homeowners.
- Each country's purchase taxes and fees: enter your own estimate as the purchase costs.
- Rate changes on a variable or mixed-rate mortgage, early repayments and insurance tied to the loan.
- Whether the payments are affordable: both paths assume the higher of the two costs is paid from income every month.
- The calculator accepts home prices up to €100,000,000, rent up to €1,000,000 a month, growth and return rates from -10% to 15% a year, and up to 40 years.
Related calculators
To see the loan on its own, with its schedule year by year, use the mortgage calculator.
To add up the home, the loan and your savings as they stand today, use the net worth calculator.
This calculator is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or tax advice. Figures shown are estimates — consult a qualified financial advisor before making financial decisions.
Related content
Mortgage Calculator
Work out the monthly payment on a fixed-rate home loan, the interest it costs and how the balance falls each year.
ViewCalculatorNet Worth Calculator
Calculate your total net worth by adding up all your assets and subtracting liabilities.
ViewCalculatorCompound Interest Calculator
See how an initial amount and monthly contributions grow, before and after inflation.
ViewFollow the decision in your net-worth plan
Add your home, your mortgage and your investments to WonderMoney and follow your net worth over the years, whichever path you take.
Free and open source. Use it here or host your own.